Przeglądaj wg Autor "Piechowiak, Marek"

Teraz wyświetlane 1 - 1 z 1

Petera Knauera koncepcja wyboru moralnego. W sprawie kreatywizmu antropologicznego we współczesnej teologii moralnej
Piechowiak, Marek (Towarzystwo Naukowe KUL, 1990)
The author undertakes a critical analysis of the ethical views of Peter Knauer who is one of the most influential theological moralist today. The author tends to show the consequences of Knauer’s theory which consequences are destructive for morality. The first part of the paper presents Knauer’s standpoint in view of the conception of moral choice and shows three crucial points of his system. They are the following: the definition of moral good (rightness) in its relation to physical good; the reinterpretation of the principle of double effect which reinterpretation reduces that principle to its “teleological explanation”; and, finally, the conception of the so-called non-counterproductivity which decides whether an activity is right. That non-counterproductivity is comprehended as an all-embracing correspondence between the goals which the subject has chosen and means which the subject has taken in order to accomplish the goals. In the second critical part one finds some questions related to the immanent critique of the discussed theory and some consequences of Knauer’s claims. If one applies his assumptions strictly, it turns out that in his model of morality there is no place for such an activity of man which, at the same time, would be both rational and free, i.e., sensu stricto moral. In view of Knauer’s system the criteria of moral evaluation, which criteria he proposed, do not hold sense. Thus morality and ethics lose their essential normative character. Consequently, the system under scrutiny leads to an antipersonalistic vision of both an individual and society, and in terms of eternity it seems to dismiss the possibility of recognizing the existence of Absolute. The theory rejects values for the sake of which it was construed.